Local restaurants in Youngstown & Mahoning County are offering dine-in options and carryout dinners this Thanksgiving 2021. Contact each restaurant directly to make reservations or place your order. Pick-up days and times vary.
Dine-In Thanksgiving Day
Cafe 422
8586 South Ave., Boardman, 330-629-2422
Café 422 in Boardman will be open from 12:00pm-4:00pm on Thanksgiving Day. They have a three course Thanksgiving Day menu for $29.99 per person. Call 330-629-2422 to make your reservations.
The Vineyards at Pine Lake – Thanksgiving Buffet
14101 Market Street, Columbiana, 330-549-0195
Thursday, November 25, seatings at 11:00am, 12:00pm and 1:00pm. Menu includes turkey, carved ham, stuffing, mashed potatoes, sweet potato casserole, green beans, corn, cranberry sauce, house salad with ranch and Italian dressing, house made rolls, assorted desserts, soda bar, water and coffee. Ticket costs are as follows: Adults $26.00, Seniors $22.00 (65 & older), Children (6-12) $14.00, and Children (5 and Under) Free.
Waypoint 4180 – Thanksgiving Grand Buffet
4180 Westford Place, Canfield, 330-286-3864
Thursday, November 25, reservations from 12:00pm-4:00pm. Call 330-533-6692 by November 22 at 2:00pm. Featuring a carving station with roasted turkey, honey glazed ham, top round of beef, and smoked salmon bar; Waypoint salad, classic Caesar salad, assorted bread board, butter crumb pesto haddock, oven roasted turkey breast and thighs, creamy red skin mashed potatoes, buttered whole kernel corn, traditional bread dressing, green bean casserole, candied yams, dessert bar, coffee, tea, iced tea, soft drinks, and a cash bar. Adults $34, kids 12 & under $14, kids 6 & under free. Plus tax and gratuity.
Carryout Options
Cafe 422 – Thanksgiving Dinner Family Packages
8586 South Ave., Boardman, 330-629-2422
Family packages are available. Call 330-629-2422 to pre-order by Wednesday, November 24. Pick up is Thanksgiving Day, 11am & 12pm. Sliced roast turkey breast with stuffing and gravy, sliced baked ham with orange marmalade, garlic mashed potatoes with gravy, green bean almondine, fresh gathered greens with house dressing, bread and butter, and homemade pumpkin pie. 4-6 people for $150, 8-10 people for $225. 18-22 lb. whole turkey dinner includes stuffing, gravy, sides & homemade pumpkin pie. Serves 8-10 for $249.00. Individual dinners are available and include choice of entrée, sides and dessert for $29.99 each.
Jeff Chrystal Catering – Thanksgiving Dinner
2315 Belmont Ave., Youngstown, 330-743-8062
Orders must be placed by Monday, November 22 and can be picked up on Thanksgiving Day between 11:00am and 3:00pm at 2315 Belmont Avenue. Call 330-743-8062 to place your order. Dinners to Go: Cherry wood spit or slow roasted turkey, sage stuffing, whipped potatoes with pan sauce, steamed vegetables, candied yams, cranberry sauce, salad with vinaigrette, homemade bread, and pumpkin pie. Large feeds 12-14 guests – $425.00; Small feeds 6-8 guests – $340.00. Individual Dinners: Roasted turkey breast, whipped potatoes with pan sauce, sage stuffing, vegetable medley, candied yams, cranberry sauce, garden salad with vinaigrette, slice of homemade bread, and slice of pumpkin pie. $28.50 per dinner. Whole pies and homemade loaves of bread available.
Napa Grocery – Take-home Thanksgiving Feast
4350 Boardman-Canfield Rd., Canfield, 330-286-3136
Packed cold with reheat instructions. Includes sliced turkey breast, mashed potatoes, sausage stuffing, green beans with pancetta, turkey gravy, house made cranberry sauce, Italian rolls, tossed salad with vinaigrette, and pumpkin pie. Feed 6-8 people $159, or feed 12-16 people $289. Add-ons include shrimp cocktail, sausage stuffed peppers, and chocolate bourbon pecan pie. Place your orders by November 17. Pick-up is November 24 from 5-7pm. Place orders online at ilovenapagrocery.com.
Homemade Pies
Molnar Farms
3115 E. Western Reserve Rd., Poland, 330-757-3142
Order your Thanksgiving pies, pumpkin rolls, kolachi, butter horn rolls and more on their website. Orders are due by 5:00pm on Monday, November 22. Items will be available for pick up Wednesday, November 24 from 12:00pm-4:00pm.
Selah Restaurant
130 S. Bridge Street, Struthers, 330-755-2759
Thanksgiving Bakery Orders. Everything baked from scratch, just like grandma used to make. Coconut cream pie $16, crumb-topped pumpkin pie $16, pistachio cake $26, Italian creme cake $26, banana salted caramel cake $26, sour cream potato bread loaf $6, basil bread loaf $6, olive tapenade tub $5, homemade sweet butter tub $5. Download order form at https://www.selahrestaurant.com/bakery. Call in your order no later than Tuesday, November 23, 330-755-2759. All pick ups are after 2:00pm on Wednesday, November 24.
White House Fruit Farm
9249 State Route 62, Canfield, 330-533-4161
Your Thanksgiving Feast isn’t complete without dessert and you can order pies from White House Fruit Farm. They offer apple, pumpkin, pecan, cherry, fruits of the forest, and many more. Visit their website for a full list of pies, then call ahead to order yours at 330-533-4161 or stop in and place an order so you are sure to get what you want. Your Thanksgiving orders can be picked up on Tuesday or Wednesday of that week. All pies are 10 inch. They also sell frozen take & bake pies.
Listing last updated 11/9/2021
